06 May 2024
Bilbao
Dr. Gustavo de la Orden Bosch has been awarded the Ignacio Ellacuría Extraordinary Prize for the Best Doctoral Thesis of 2022-23 for his work titled "The Right to Asylum in the Face of the Criminalisation of Irregular Migration at the External Borders of the European Union: Spain as a Case Study". España como un caso de estudio". This research, led by Joana Abrisketa Uriarte and María Nagore Casas, analyses how the criminalisation of irregular migration affects the right to seek asylum at the external borders of the European Union (EU), with a special focus on Spanish borders.
The study is based on the premise that the lack of regular channels of access to the territory in the EU leads to the search for international protection through irregular migratory routes. In such circumstances, the thesis hypothesis argues that the association between protection seekers and irregular migrants extends the elements of the criminalisation of irregular migration - containment, immobility, and expulsion - into the asylum system.
The research interest lies in the fact that the pursuit of international protection often drives individuals to resort to irregular routes. It is reasonable to consider that the forced nature, often urgent, of displacement may de facto hinder the possibility of meeting the conditions required for regular border crossings. This is acknowledged both by international refugee law, which prohibits penalising asylum seekers in situations of irregular migration, and by EU law, which provides specific criteria for determining the responsible state for the application when entry occurs irregularly.
In this context, the thesis aims to understand the legal conditions under which the right to asylum remains amidst the series of cascading processes that govern migrations today. In this regard, two main questions are raised: what safeguards does the law provide to counteract the negative impact of criminalisation on the asylum system? And to what extent does the law itself contribute to the expansion of criminalisation into the asylum system?
The main findings show that the criminalisation of migration affects access to the right to asylum at external borders, making international protection more challenging for those who resort to irregular displacement routes.
The thesis contributes to understanding the combination of penal power and migration control from both legal and criminological perspectives, exploring the role of international law, the EU, and Spain in regulating these mechanisms. Additionally, it highlights the importance of addressing Spanish immigration and asylum law as an object of interest for legal science, emphasising its relevance in ensuring the coherence of the legal system and respect for human rights.